6 Ways to Upgrade Your Closet: Which One is Right for You?

The Problem: Too Many Options

Upgrading your closet can transform your space, making it more functional and visually appealing. But with so many options, how do you decide what’s best for your needs and budget? Let’s break down six popular closet upgrade methods, weighing the pros and cons of each.

A small Closet that the owner could have done themselves, but called us instead.

1. IKEA, Lowes, or Home Depot Closet Systems

Pros:

• Often perceived as budget-friendly

• Can be a temporary upgrade for dorms, rental properties, or apartments

• Easy to find and purchase at a local store when you're ready to start

• Modular and customizable to some extent

Cons:

• No customization beyond pre-set sizes, styles, and colors

• Assembly required, often with only picture-based instructions

• Quality is debated because it's longevity depends on careful installation and proper usage

📝 Best for: Renters, installs not in a children's closet, people already familiar with similar product assembly, and DIYers on a very limited budget.

2. Custom Built DIY

Buying lumber from a home improvement store and following one of the many available online guides (Youtube, DIY blogs, etc) allows for a more custom buildout, but it requires skill and patience.

Pros:

• Full creative control over materials and design, if your budget is large enough

• Can be cost-effective if you have the tools, skills, and a source for bargain-priced lumber

• Sense of accomplishment felt after project is completed

Cons:

• Requires advanced woodworking skills and tools to complete

• EXTREMELY time-consuming and error-prone, potentially eliminating cost savings

• Requires sanding, priming, and multiple coats of paint

• limited adjustability once built

• solid wood or plywood is prone to warping, cracking, and is hard to achieve a smooth finish

• No warranty or professional support

📝 Best for: Skilled DIYers who enjoy woodworking and have the necessary tools.

3. Online Closet Suppliers

Pros:

• Easier and more numerous customization options than other DIY closet systems

• Can approach professional-grade quality in some cases

• Online design tools available, along with free design assistance if needed

• Ships directly to your home

Cons:

• May not fit your space perfectly (pre-set widths and depths)

• Requires self-installation, which can be challenging and more time-consuming than expected

• The amount of materials delivered is easy to underestimate, and you have to have a plan for where to store it and dispose of waste

📝 Best for: Homeowners who want semi-custom solutions and are confident in their ability to install them.

If you have multiple closets for your DIY project, be prepared for a BIG truck to deliver a BIG pallet to your home. And you'll need to take care of all that waste when you're done.

4. Hiring a Local Handyman

Pros:

• Sometimes more affordable than a dedicated closet company

• Can install prefabricated systems professionally

• You may have hired them before and trust their capabilities

• Less effort required on your part

Cons:

• Skill levels vary widely—results depend on the handyman’s expertise and experience

• May not specialize in closets, leading to design inefficiencies

• Scheduling delays and lack of communication are common, depending on who you hire

• Limited post-installation support or warranty

📝 Best for: Homeowners who need installation help but aren’t looking for a fully custom closet.

5. Budget-Friendly Closet Companies

Pros:

• Professionally installed

• More customization than DIY kits

• Affordable compared to high-end brands

Cons:

• Fewer premium material options

• Limited to standardized heights, widths, and depths

• May lack high-end finishes you desire

• Limited flexibility in terms of accessories and upgrades

📝 Best for: Homeowners looking for an affordable, professional installation with moderate customization.

6. Full-Custom Closet Companies

Pros:

• Custom-built to maximize your space efficiently

• High-quality materials with luxury upgrade options

• Fast, professional overall experience with minimal/ zero hassle

• Premium materials and finishes

• Extra care is taken to protect your floors and walls during installation

• Professional design services and installation

Cons:

• Often has a higher initial investment when compared to the other options

• Popular national brands may have longer lead times, sometimes more than 8 weeks

• May offer more features than some homeowners need

📝 Best for: Homeowners who want a perfectly designed closet that maximizes storage, provides a seamless experience, and serves as a lasting investment in their home and daily life.

What’s the Best Option for You?

Your perfect solution will balance value and convenience, giving you the storage, quality, and service you can invest in comfortably.

At Captain Closet, we believe we can help guide you toward the best closet solution for your needs.

If you're unsure which option is right for you, we’d love to help. Whether you’re ready to start designing or just exploring possibilities, we can guide you toward the best solution for your needs.

🚀 Need more help? Click "Get Your Free Consultation" below!